[mlir][IR] Trigger notifyOperationReplaced on replaceAllOpUsesWith (#84721)

Before this change: `notifyOperationReplaced` was triggered when calling
`RewriteBase::replaceOp`.
After this change: `notifyOperationReplaced` is triggered when
`RewriterBase::replaceAllOpUsesWith` or `RewriterBase::replaceOp` is
called.

Until now, every `notifyOperationReplaced` was always sent together with
a `notifyOperationErased`, which made that `notifyOperationErased`
callback irrelevant. More importantly, when a user called
`RewriterBase::replaceAllOpUsesWith`+`RewriterBase::eraseOp` instead of
`RewriterBase::replaceOp`, no `notifyOperationReplaced` callback was
sent, even though the two notations are semantically equivalent. As an
example, this can be a problem when applying patterns with the transform
dialect because the `TrackingListener` will only see the
`notifyOperationErased` callback and the payload op is dropped from the
mappings.

Note: It is still possible to write semantically equivalent code that
does not trigger a `notifyOperationReplaced` (e.g., when op results are
replaced one-by-one), but this commit already improves the situation a
lot.

Author: matthias-springer

mlir/include/mlir/IR/PatternMatch.h

@@ -409,9 +409,9 @@ class RewriterBase : public OpBuilder {
     /// Notify the listener that the specified operation was modified in-place.
     virtual void notifyOperationModified(Operation *op) {}
 
-    /// Notify the listener that the specified operation is about to be replaced
-    /// with another operation. This is called before the uses of the old
-    /// operation have been changed.
+    /// Notify the listener that all uses of the specified operation's results
+    /// are about to be replaced with the results of another operation. This is
+    /// called before the uses of the old operation have been changed.
     ///
     /// By default, this function calls the "operation replaced with values"
     /// notification.
@@ -420,9 +420,10 @@ class RewriterBase : public OpBuilder {
       notifyOperationReplaced(op, replacement->getResults());
     }
 
-    /// Notify the listener that the specified operation is about to be replaced
-    /// with the a range of values, potentially produced by other operations.
-    /// This is called before the uses of the operation have been changed.
+    /// Notify the listener that all uses of the specified operation's results
+    /// are about to be replaced with the a range of values, potentially
+    /// produced by other operations. This is called before the uses of the
+    /// operation have been changed.
     virtual void notifyOperationReplaced(Operation *op,
                                          ValueRange replacement) {}
 
@@ -648,12 +649,16 @@ class RewriterBase : public OpBuilder {
     for (auto it : llvm::zip(from, to))
       replaceAllUsesWith(std::get<0>(it), std::get<1>(it));
   }
-  // Note: This function cannot be called `replaceAllUsesWith` because the
-  // overload resolution, when called with an op that can be implicitly
-  // converted to a Value, would be ambiguous.
-  void replaceAllOpUsesWith(Operation *from, ValueRange to) {
-    replaceAllUsesWith(from->getResults(), to);
-  }
+
+  /// Find uses of `from` and replace them with `to`. Also notify the listener
+  /// about every in-place op modification (for every use that was replaced)
+  /// and that the `from` operation is about to be replaced.
+  ///
+  /// Note: This function cannot be called `replaceAllUsesWith` because the
+  /// overload resolution, when called with an op that can be implicitly
+  /// converted to a Value, would be ambiguous.
+  void replaceAllOpUsesWith(Operation *from, ValueRange to);
+  void replaceAllOpUsesWith(Operation *from, Operation *to);
 
   /// Find uses of `from` and replace them with `to` if the `functor` returns
   /// true. Also notify the listener about every in-place op modification (for

mlir/lib/IR/PatternMatch.cpp

@@ -110,17 +110,29 @@ RewriterBase::~RewriterBase() {
   // Out of line to provide a vtable anchor for the class.
 }
 
+void RewriterBase::replaceAllOpUsesWith(Operation *from, ValueRange to) {
+  // Notify the listener that we're about to replace this op.
+  if (auto *rewriteListener = dyn_cast_if_present<Listener>(listener))
+    rewriteListener->notifyOperationReplaced(from, to);
+
+  replaceAllUsesWith(from->getResults(), to);
+}
+
+void RewriterBase::replaceAllOpUsesWith(Operation *from, Operation *to) {
+  // Notify the listener that we're about to replace this op.
+  if (auto *rewriteListener = dyn_cast_if_present<Listener>(listener))
+    rewriteListener->notifyOperationReplaced(from, to);
+
+  replaceAllUsesWith(from->getResults(), to->getResults());
+}
+
 /// This method replaces the results of the operation with the specified list of
 /// values. The number of provided values must match the number of results of
 /// the operation. The replaced op is erased.
 void RewriterBase::replaceOp(Operation *op, ValueRange newValues) {
   assert(op->getNumResults() == newValues.size() &&
          "incorrect # of replacement values");
 
-  // Notify the listener that we're about to replace this op.
-  if (auto *rewriteListener = dyn_cast_if_present<Listener>(listener))
-    rewriteListener->notifyOperationReplaced(op, newValues);
-
   // Replace all result uses. Also notifies the listener of modifications.
   replaceAllOpUsesWith(op, newValues);
 
@@ -136,10 +148,6 @@ void RewriterBase::replaceOp(Operation *op, Operation *newOp) {
   assert(op->getNumResults() == newOp->getNumResults() &&
          "ops have different number of results");
 
-  // Notify the listener that we're about to replace this op.
-  if (auto *rewriteListener = dyn_cast_if_present<Listener>(listener))
-    rewriteListener->notifyOperationReplaced(op, newOp);
-
   // Replace all result uses. Also notifies the listener of modifications.
   replaceAllOpUsesWith(op, newOp->getResults());
 

mlir/test/lib/Dialect/Test/TestPatterns.cpp

@@ -489,7 +489,10 @@ struct TestStrictPatternDriver
             OperationName("test.new_op", op->getContext()).getIdentifier(),
             op->getOperands(), op->getResultTypes());
       }
-      rewriter.replaceOp(op, newOp->getResults());
+      // "replaceOp" could be used instead of "replaceAllOpUsesWith"+"eraseOp".
+      // A "notifyOperationReplaced" callback is triggered in either case.
+      rewriter.replaceAllOpUsesWith(op, newOp->getResults());
+      rewriter.eraseOp(op);
       return success();
     }
   };