Skip to content

Update Analysis View Mockup with detailed issue listing format #8

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Merged
merged 1 commit into from
Apr 29, 2025
Merged
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
282 changes: 282 additions & 0 deletions ANALYSIS_VIEW_MOCKUP.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,282 @@
# Codegen SDK Analysis View Mockup

This document provides a mockup of how the analysis results would be presented when using the Codegen SDK for codebase analysis.

## 1. Overall Statistics

```
------ Overall statistics
Total Files: 324
- Python: 187 (57.7%)
- JavaScript: 98 (30.2%)
- TypeScript: 39 (12.0%)
Total Lines of Code: 45,892
```

## 2. Most Important Files & Codebase Flow

```
--------- Important Codefiles which are main files
Top Level operators- and Entry point analysis:
(To find all program's functional entrypoints).

• src/core/processor.py - method process_data (input: Dict[str, Any], output: ProcessedResult)
• src/api/server.py - method start_server (input: ServerConfig, output: ServerInstance)
• src/cli/main.py - function main (input: CommandLineArgs, output: ExitCode)
• src/utils/analyzer.py - class Analyzer - method run_analysis (input: CodebaseContext, output: AnalysisReport)

------------ How project is functioning from each of the main entrypoint files
- Entry point flow diagrams

1. src/core/processor.py - process_data:
process_data → validate_input → transform_data → apply_filters → generate_output

2. src/api/server.py - start_server:
start_server → initialize_routes → setup_middleware → configure_database → start_listening

3. src/cli/main.py - main:
main → parse_arguments → initialize_logger → execute_command → handle_result
```

## 3. Project Tree Structure with Context

```
Full project's tree structure with informational context - to highlight specific parts that have issues.
(to get full project's scope comprehension and where are the issues located)

my-project/
├── src/ (42 files)
│ ├── core/ (17 files)
│ │ ├── processor.py (3-classes 17-functions 488 lines)
│ │ │ ├── class Processor
│ │ │ │ ├── method __init__ (lines 7 - 26)
│ │ │ │ ├── method process_data (lines 32 - 78)
│ │ │ │ └── method validate_input (lines 80 - 95)
│ │ │ └── function initialize_processor (lines 98 - 120)
│ │ └── transformer.py (2-classes 8-functions 256 lines)
│ │ ├── class Transformer
│ │ │ ├── method __init__ (lines 5 - 18)
│ │ │ └── method transform_output (lines 20 - 45)
│ │ └── function apply_transformation (lines 48 - 72)
│ └── utils/ (25 files)
│ └── validator.py (1-class 5-functions 142 lines)
│ ├── class Validator
│ │ ├── method __init__ (lines 8 - 15)
│ │ └── method validate (lines 17 - 42)
│ └── function is_valid (lines 45 - 60)
└── tests/ (18 files)
└── test_processor.py (1-class 6-functions 189 lines)
└── class TestProcessor
├── method setUp (lines 10 - 22)
├── method test_process_data (lines 24 - 56)
└── method test_validate_input (lines 58 - 75)
```

## 4. List of All Issues

```
:mag: CODE QUALITY ISSUES - second section that lists all issues
------------------------------------------

ISSUES: 172

1. "Unused import 'os' in src/core/processor.py line 3"
2. "Unused import 'json' in src/utils/helpers.py line 5"
3. "Unused import 'datetime' in src/api/models.py line 8"
4. "Unused function 'validate_email' in src/utils/validator.py line 78"
5. "Unused function 'transform_legacy_format' in src/core/transformer.py line 112"
6. "Unused class 'LegacyUserModel' in src/models/legacy.py line 56"
7. "Unused class 'JSONFormatter' in src/utils/formatters.py line 23"
8. "Function call issue: missing required parameter 'timeout' in src/api/client.py - function make_request"
9. "Function call issue: incorrect parameter type for 'data' in src/core/processor.py - method process_data"
10. "Parameter issue: parameter 'user_id' should be int, not str in src/api/handlers.py - function process_request"
11. "Parameter issue: parameter 'options' missing default value in src/utils/validator.py - function validate_input"
12. "Interface implementation issue: missing required method 'disconnect' in src/api/providers/aws.py - class AWSProvider"
13. "Interface implementation issue: incorrect signature for method 'query' in src/data/storage/sql.py - class SQLStorage"
...
172. "Duplicate code block in src/utils/exporters.py (lines 120-137) matches src/utils/formatters.py (lines 78-95)"
```

## 5. Issues Categorized

```
------------------------------------------
Unused Imports: 134 (7.1%) / 1,876
List Filenames and imports:
- src/core/processor.py: from datetime import datetime, timedelta (timedelta unused)
- src/utils/validator.py: import json, yaml, toml (toml unused)
- src/api/routes.py: from fastapi import FastAPI, Request, Response, HTTPException (Response unused)
- src/models/user.py: from typing import List, Dict, Optional, Union, Any (Union, Any unused)
------------
Unused Functions: 45
- src/utils/validator.py - class TestProcessor - Unused = method validate
- src/utils/formatter.py - transform_output
- src/core/transformer.py - process_data
- src/api/helpers.py - generate_response_headers
- src/models/base.py - to_dict
------------
Unused Classes: 12
- src/utils/validator.py - Unused = class TestProcessor
- src/utils/validator.py - Unused = class TestExample
- src/models/deprecated/user_v1.py - Unused = class UserV1
- src/core/legacy/processor_old.py - Unused = class OldProcessor
------------
Duplicate Code Blocks: 28

Location and codeblocks:
1. src/utils/formatter.py (lines 45-67) and src/utils/transformer.py (lines 112-134)
```python
def format_output(data, options=None):
if options is None:
options = {}
result = {}
for key, value in data.items():
if isinstance(value, dict):
result[key] = format_output(value, options)
elif isinstance(value, list):
result[key] = [format_output(item, options) if isinstance(item, dict) else item for item in value]
else:
result[key] = value
return result
```

2. src/core/processor.py (lines 156-172) and src/api/handlers.py (lines 78-94)
```python
def validate_input(data):
if not isinstance(data, dict):
raise ValueError("Input must be a dictionary")
required_fields = ["id", "name", "type"]
for field in required_fields:
if field not in data:
raise ValueError(f"Missing required field: {field}")
return True
```
------------
Issues with Function Call in/out points: 72
(From Call site tracking and Function call relationships)

- src/core/processor.py/process_data - Called with incorrect parameter types in 5 locations
- src/utils/validator.py/validate_input - Missing required parameters in 3 locations
- src/api/routes.py/register_routes - Incorrect return value handling in 4 locations
- src/models/user.py/User.from_dict - Passing non-dict values in 2 locations
------------
Input/output parameter analysis
Valid 1726 parameters
Issues 11 parameters:
1. /src/core/processor.py/Processor/process_data/options - Type mismatch (expected Dict, received List)
2. /src/api/routes.py/create_user/user_data - Missing validation for required fields
3. /src/utils/formatter.py/format_output/data - Null value passed without null check
4. /src/models/transaction.py/Transaction/validate/amount - Negative values not handled
5. /src/core/analyzer.py/analyze_code/filepath - Non-existent file paths not handled
------------
Interface implementation verification:
Valid: 71 components
Issues: 6 components:
1. src/models/user.tsx - UserComponent doesn't implement all required UserProps
2. src/components/form.tsx - FormInput missing required onChange handler
3. src/views/dashboard.tsx - DashboardView implements deprecated IDashboard interface
4. src/api/client.ts - ApiClient missing required error handling methods
5. src/utils/formatter.tsx - DataFormatter missing required format method
6. src/components/table.tsx - TableComponent not implementing required sorting functionality
```

## 6. Visualization Types

```
ALL VISUALIZATION TYPES
Selection 1- type (Example - hierarchy, dependency)
after selecting 1-> 2nd selection is corresponding parameter (example -call hierarchy, symbol hierarchy, Inheritance hierarchy)
Again- corresponding parameter selection (if applicable)- (For example - codefile / class / method)

Hierarchy Visualizations:
- Call hierarchy visualization
- By file: src/core/processor.py
- By class: Processor
- By method: process_data
- Symbol hierarchy visualization
- By module: src/core
- By file: src/core/processor.py
- By class: Processor
- Inheritance hierarchy visualization
- By class: BaseProcessor

Dependency Visualizations:
- Module dependency visualization
- By module: src/core
- By file: src/core/processor.py
- Symbol dependency visualization
- By class: Processor
- By function: process_data

Flow Visualizations:
- Function call visualization
- By function: process_data
- By class method: Processor.validate_input
- Package structure visualization
- Full project
- By module: src/core
- Variable usage tracking
- By variable: config
- By class attribute: Processor.options
```

## Suggested Views

### Essential Data Context Preview

For the Essential Data Context Preview, I recommend a dashboard-style view that provides an immediate overview of the codebase health and structure:

1. **Top-Level Statistics Panel**
- File counts by language
- Total lines of code
- Number of critical issues

2. **Entry Points Panel**
- List of main entry points with their locations
- Quick links to view flow diagrams for each entry point

3. **Issues Summary Panel**
- Categorized counts of issues (unused imports, functions, classes)
- Top files with most issues with links

4. **Project Structure Panel**
- Interactive tree view of the project structure
- Color-coded indicators for files with issues

5. **Visualization Selector**
- Quick access to the most commonly used visualizations
- Preset views for common analysis tasks (dependency analysis)

### Full Specific Issues View

For the Full Specific Issues View, I recommend a detailed, filterable list of all issues with context:

1. **Issue Browser**
- Filterable list of all issues by type, severity, location
- Sorting options (by file, by issue type, by severity)
- Grouping options (by module, by class, by issue type)

2. **Issue Detail Panel**
- When selecting an issue, show full context:
- File location with line numbers
- Surrounding code snippet
- Issue description and severity
- Suggested fix or best practice reference
- Similar issues elsewhere in the codebase

3. **Code Flow Analysis**
- For function/method issues, show call graph
- For import issues, show dependency graph
- For class issues, show inheritance hierarchy
- For variable issues, show usage tracking

4. **Historical Context**
- When available, show when the issue was introduced
- Show if the issue is new or recurring
- Track if similar issues have been fixed elsewhere

5. **Actionable Recommendations**
- Specific, actionable steps to resolve each issue
- Code examples of proper implementation
- Links to relevant documentation or best practices

Loading